1. Home>
  2. Resources>
  3. Payroll & Reward>
Payroll

Payroll Software for Small Businesses: What You Actually Need

Payroll software for small businesses does three jobs: it works out what each person is owed and what comes off their pay, it reports that to HMRC on or before payday, and it produces the payslips your people are legally entitled to. Everything else is useful rather than essential. This guide covers the features that genuinely matter at this size, what free software does and does not cover, how pricing works, how to choose, and the one question most buying guides skip: whether you want software you run yourself, or someone else running payroll for you.
 

At a glance

  • Any software you use to run payroll has to report to HMRC online, so HMRC recognition is the first thing to check, not the last. > Must-have features
     
  • HMRC's free tool is built for businesses with fewer than 10 employees, and some free software will not produce payslips, handle pension contributions, or pay people on different pay frequencies. > Free options
     
  • Auto-enrolment is where the time goes. Assessing staff every pay period, writing to them and sending contribution files is the difference between software that helps and software that leaves you doing it by hand. > Must-have features
     
  • Most payroll software is priced per employee per month, with setup, payslip portals and pension handling sometimes charged separately. > What it costs
     
  • Software still means you run the payroll. If that sits with one person who also does three other jobs, a payroll service may suit you better. > Software or service?
     
  • Irregular hours, weekly pay and overtime are what break entry-level systems, not headcount. > Must-have features
     
  • The easiest time to switch is the start of a tax year or a tax month, with one parallel run behind you. > Getting set up
     

    Do you need payroll software, or a payroll service?

    Worth settling this first, because it changes everything that follows.

    Payroll software is a tool you operate. You enter the hours and changes, you check the figures, you approve the pay run, you submit to HMRC. The software does the calculations and the filing, and the responsibility for getting it right stays with you.

    A payroll service means someone else runs it. You send the changes, a payroll team processes the pay run, submits to HMRC and deals with the queries. You still supply the information, and the quality of what you send still shapes the result, but the processing and the specialist knowledge sit outside your business.

    Both are legitimate. The honest answer depends less on how many people you employ than on how complicated your pay is and how much time you have.
     

    Which route fits

    Two sets of conditions. Most employers recognise themselves in one column fairly quickly.
     

    Software tends to suit you if A service tends to suit you if
    Pay is mostly predictable. Salaried staff, one pay frequency, few changes month to month.

    Someone owns it. A person in the business is comfortable with the admin and has the time each cycle.

    You want control and visibility. You would rather see the pay run yourself before it goes.

    Cost matters more than time. Software is usually the cheaper option in cash terms, because you supply the labour.
    Pay varies a lot. Weekly cycles, overtime, shift allowances, irregular hours, lots of starters and leavers.

    Nobody in the business knows payroll. The knowledge sits with one person, or with nobody.

    The risk of one person being away worries you. Holiday, illness or a resignation should not put payday at risk.

    Your time is worth more elsewhere. The hours spent on payroll are hours not spent on the business.


     

    In practice: a 12-person cafe paying weekly, with hours that change every week and staff turning over through the year, is doing far more payroll work than a 40-person agency where everyone is salaried and nothing changes. Headcount is a poor guide. Pay patterns are a good one.

    If you are still deciding, our guide to payroll services for small businesses covers the other routes and what they cost. If you have landed on software, the rest of this page is for you.

      What payroll software actually does

      At its simplest, payroll software turns what someone earned into what lands in their bank account, and tells HMRC about it.
       

      Every pay run

      • Gross to net. It takes gross pay and works out Income Tax using the employee's tax code, National Insurance, student and postgraduate loan deductions, pension contributions and any other deductions, leaving net pay.
      • Statutory payments. Sick pay, maternity pay, paternity pay and the rest of the family leave payments, calculated against the qualifying rules rather than by hand.
      • RTI reporting. Real Time Information is HMRC's system for payroll reporting. Your software sends a Full Payment Submission (an FPS) telling HMRC what you paid and what you deducted, and it has to go on or before payday. Where you have nothing to report in a tax month, or you are reclaiming statutory payments, it sends an Employer Payment Summary (an EPS) instead.
      • Payslips. Produced for every pay run and delivered to your people on or before payday.


       

      Every month and every year

      The software also works out what you owe HMRC each month, produces P45s for leavers and P60s at year end, sends your final submission for the tax year, and keeps the records behind all of it. Good software gives you a report you or your accountant can post straight into the accounts.

      Key takeaway: the calculation is the easy part. What you are really buying is the reporting, the statutory rules and the fact that all of it updates itself every April.

        The features you cannot do without

        These are the capabilities that decide whether payroll software is genuinely doing the job. Everything in the next section is optional. Nothing in this one is.
         

        HMRC recognition and RTI

        Your software must report PAYE information online, unless you are one of the few employers exempt from doing so. In practice that means using software from HMRC's list of recognised payroll software. A spreadsheet cannot file an FPS, so a spreadsheet is not an option, however small you are.

        Late filing carries penalties that scale with headcount: £100 a month for 1 to 9 employees, £200 for 10 to 49, £300 for 50 to 249 and £400 for 250 or more. HMRC does not charge for your first late submission in a tax year, gives new employers 30 days from the first payment, and does not penalise an FPS that arrives within three days of payday, though filing late as a habit will attract attention.

        What to ask: is the software on HMRC's recognised list, and does it submit the FPS and the EPS directly rather than asking me to key anything into HMRC's website?
         

        Automatic updates every April

        Tax bands, National Insurance thresholds, the minimum wage and statutory payment rates all change at the start of the tax year, and some change mid-year. Software that updates itself is doing real work. Software that expects you to notice a change and apply it is handing you a compliance job you did not ask for.

        What to ask: are legislative updates applied automatically, included in the price, and available before 6 April rather than after it?
         

        Auto-enrolment, properly handled

        Workplace pension duties start the day your first member of staff starts working for you, not at some later threshold. You must enrol anyone aged between 22 and State Pension age who earns at least £10,000 a year and normally works in the UK, and where someone becomes eligible through a change in age or earnings you have six weeks to put them in and write to them.

        This is the single biggest time saver at this size, and the feature most often missing or charged as an extra. Full handling means assessing every worker every pay period, producing the letters, calculating contributions, and sending the contribution file to your pension provider in the format it expects. Partial handling means the software does the sums and you do the rest.

        What to ask: does it assess every pay period, produce the statutory communications, and send contributions to my pension provider directly?
         

        Payslips that meet the rules

        Payslips must be given to employees and workers on or before payday, and they must show pay before and after deductions, the amount of any deduction that varies, and the number of hours worked where pay varies with time worked. That last point catches out a lot of small employers with hourly staff, and it is a software capability question as much as a legal one. Printed or electronic is your choice.

        What to ask: does it show variable hours on the payslip, and can staff get payslips without me emailing them individually?
         

        Statutory pay and holiday

        Statutory Sick Pay is £123.25 a week or 80% of average weekly earnings, whichever is lower, for up to 28 weeks, and it cannot be reclaimed. Family leave payments are different. You can usually reclaim 92% of statutory maternity, paternity, adoption, shared parental, parental bereavement and neonatal care pay through an EPS, and 109% if you paid £45,000 or less in Class 1 National Insurance in the last complete tax year. Your software should work the reclaim out and put it on the EPS for you.

        Holiday is where entry-level software most often falls short. For leave years beginning on or after 1 April 2024, workers on irregular hours and part-year workers accrue holiday at 12.07% of the hours they actually work in each pay period, and rolled-up holiday pay is permitted for those workers. If you employ anyone on variable hours, software that tracks this is worth more to you than any dashboard.

        What to ask: does it calculate holiday for irregular hours staff, and does it handle statutory payment recovery through the EPS?
         

        Minimum wage checks and record keeping

        Pay has to clear the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage for the worker's age, and deductions or salary sacrifice can quietly push an hourly rate under the floor. Software that flags this before you approve the run saves a difficult conversation later.

        You must keep PAYE records for three years from the end of the tax year they relate to, and HMRC can charge up to £3,000 where records are inadequate. Minimum wage records run longer: at least six years for anything created since April 2021. Software that stores your pay records properly is doing part of this job for you, which matters if you ever face a minimum wage check.

          Important: the sick pay rules changed in April 2026. Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, the three waiting days and the earnings threshold were both removed. Statutory Sick Pay is now payable from the first full working day an employee is off sick, and employees who previously earned too little to qualify now do. If you are choosing software, or still running something you set up before April 2026, check it applies the current rules rather than the old ones. Older guides and older systems still describe three unpaid days.

            Features worth paying for as you grow

            None of these are compliance requirements. All of them save time once you are past a handful of people.

            • Employee self-service. Staff view their own payslips and P60s and update their details, instead of asking you. The single biggest reduction in payroll admin for most employers, and it removes the risk of emailing a payslip to the wrong person.
            • Absence and holiday tracking. Booked and taken leave feeding into payroll rather than living in a separate spreadsheet.
            • Time and attendance. Recorded hours flowing into the pay run without rekeying. Worth it the moment you have hourly staff, shift premiums or overtime.
            • Accounting integration. Payroll journals posting into your accounts package automatically, rather than being typed in each month.
            • More than one pay frequency. Weekly and monthly staff in the same system. Not every entry-level package supports both, so check before you buy if you run a split payroll.
            • More than one company. Useful if you are a director with several companies, or a group with separate PAYE schemes.
            • Accountant or bookkeeper access. A separate login beats emailing files back and forth, and it matters if your accountant currently runs the payroll for you.
            • Reporting. Pay cost by department, by site or by period. Modest payroll reporting is enough for most employers at this size.

            In practice: a 40-person agency with salaried staff gets most of its value from self-service and accounting integration. A 120-person manufacturer with overtime and shift allowances gets it from time and attendance, because that is where the errors are made.

              Free payroll software: what it covers and what it does not

              Free is a reasonable answer for a very small payroll, as long as you know the limits.
               

              HMRC Basic PAYE Tools

              HMRC publishes Basic PAYE Tools free of charge for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It calculates tax and National Insurance, submits your RTI reports and works with most current computers. You need to be registered as an employer and have a PAYE Online login before you can use it, and it is not designed for agents or bookkeepers running payroll for several clients.

              It is deliberately basic. HMRC's own guidance on choosing payroll software warns that some software will not let you produce payslips, record pension deductions, make pension payments, pay different people over different periods, or send an EPS. Those gaps matter: payslips are a legal requirement, pension contributions are a duty from the first employee, and the EPS is how you reclaim statutory payments and claim the Employment Allowance.
               

              Free tiers and spreadsheets

              HMRC's list of recognised payroll software has a free section as well as a paid one, and every free package on it carries the same limit: businesses with fewer than 10 employees. Free tiers usually come with limits on support or on features such as pension file submission. They can work well for a sole director or one or two employees. Read what happens at the point you exceed the limit, because that is usually when you need the software most.

              Spreadsheets are not an option on their own. They cannot file RTI, so whatever else you use them for, you still need recognised software. For more on recognition and what it does and does not guarantee, see HMRC-recognised payroll software.

                What payroll software costs

                Prices move, so what follows is how the pricing is built rather than what any particular package charges.
                 

                Pricing structure What it means in practice
                Per employee per month (PEPM) A set amount for each employee you pay each month, sometimes with a minimum monthly charge. The most common structure, and the easiest to forecast.

                Watch for: whether leavers count in the month they leave, and whether the minimum charge bites when you are small.
                Banded tiers A flat price for a range of employees, for example up to 10, then up to 25. Predictable until you cross a band.

                Watch for: the jump between bands, and what happens in a month when a seasonal peak pushes you over.
                Modular pricing A base price for payroll, with pension handling, a payslip portal, HR features or reporting charged separately.

                Watch for: whether auto-enrolment is in the base price, since it is the feature you will use every single pay run.
                One-off charges Setup, data migration from your current system, training, and sometimes year-end.

                Watch for: whether mid-year setup costs more, and whether historical data is included or extra.


                 


                 

                What pushes the price up

                Pay frequency, more than anything: a weekly payroll is roughly four times the processing of a monthly one. Then the number of separate PAYE schemes, the complexity of your pay (overtime, allowances, multiple rates), integrations with accounting or time systems, and the level of support you want.
                 

                The cost of your own time

                Software looks cheap next to a service because you are supplying the labour. Count the hours honestly: collecting hours and changes, running and checking the pay run, dealing with queries, sorting out the pension file, and the time spent reading up when something unusual happens. A payroll that takes a day a month is a real cost even though it never appears on an invoice. For the comparison in full, see payroll services for small businesses.

                  How to choose: a simple checklist

                  Three stages, and most of the useful work happens in the first two.
                   

                  Before you shortlist

                  1. Write down what you actually run. Headcount, pay frequencies, hourly or salaried, overtime and allowances, pension provider, who does the work today.
                  2. Separate must from nice. Use the two sections above. Anything in "cannot do without" is a filter. Anything else is a preference.
                  3. Check HMRC recognition on the government's list before you look at anything else.
                  4. Decide who else needs access. Your accountant, a bookkeeper, a second person as cover.


                   

                  During a trial

                  1. Run your own data through it, not the demo data. A real pay run with your actual staff, including anyone awkward.
                  2. Test the pension file, not just the calculation. Can it produce the file your pension provider accepts?
                  3. Look at a payslip. Does it show everything it needs to for your hourly people?
                  4. Try support. Ask a real question during the trial and see how long the answer takes and how good it is.


                   

                  Before you sign

                  1. Check what happens to your data if you leave: can you export your payroll records and employee data in a usable format?
                  2. Confirm what is included in the price and what is charged separately, especially auto-enrolment and year-end.
                  3. Check how legislative updates arrive and whether they are included.
                  4. Check support hours against your payday. Support that closes at 5pm is no help if you process at seven in the evening.

                  What to ask at the end of every demo: what do your customers most often need help with in their first three months? The answer tells you where the system is hard.

                    Getting set up without disrupting payday

                    This is the part people put off, usually because they are worried about staff not being paid correctly while the change happens. That worry is reasonable, and it is also manageable.
                     

                    What you need before you switch Where it comes from
                    Employer PAYE reference and Accounts Office reference Your HMRC registration, or your current payroll records
                    Employee records: names, addresses, NI numbers, dates of birth, start dates, tax codes, pay details Your current software, your accountant, or your employee files
                    Year-to-date figures for every employee Your current payroll, if you are moving mid-year
                    Pension scheme details and contribution rates Your pension provider
                    Holiday balances for anyone on irregular hours Your own records


                     

                    The easiest time to move is the start of a tax year, because there are no year-to-date figures to carry across. The next easiest is the start of a tax month. Either way, run one cycle in parallel with your old method and compare the results line by line before you rely on the new system.

                    Two practical points. If you are registering as an employer for the first time, do it before your first payday, because the reference takes time to arrive. And when you change software, employee payroll IDs may not carry across; where they do not, your FPS needs the payroll ID changed indicator set, or HMRC may duplicate your employee records and miscalculate your bill.

                    In our experience, the single most common cause of a messy switch is incomplete year-to-date data from the old system, not the new software itself. Get the data out and checked before you start the migration, not during it.

                      When you have outgrown your software

                      The signs are consistent: the pay run takes longer every month rather than less, you keep working around the software in spreadsheets, you are rekeying the same information into payroll and into your HR records, or you are nervous every time something unusual happens because nobody in the business is sure of the rule.

                      At that point the question changes. Some employers move to better software. Others move to a payroll service. Many move to connected systems, so that a new starter, a change of hours or a leaver is entered once and flows through to pay. If that is where you are heading, our guides to integrated HR and payroll software and HR software for small businesses cover what connecting the two actually involves, and cloud payroll software explains what you get from running payroll in the cloud rather than on a machine in the office.

                        Why SD Worx

                        We have been doing payroll since 1945, and today we process more than six million payslips a month for over 90,000 customers. Our UK payroll professionals are CIPP-certified, our technology is HMRC-recognised and GDPR-compliant, and our certifications include ISO 27001, ISAE 3000 and ISAE 3402 Type II.

                        Something that matters more than scale, if you are weighing up who knows the rules: our people sit on UK Government consultation panels including the Rep Body Group and the Employer Payroll Group, and we are active in the CIPP, IReeN and BCS. Our UK Compliance Director, Simon Parsons, fronts our monthly Payroll Question Time, where employers bring real legislative questions to a panel. It is useful whichever software you end up choosing.

                        We offer both routes. Payroll software for teams who want to run payroll themselves with better tools, and payroll for smaller businesses where our specialists run the pay run, the submissions and the queries and you keep visibility through one platform. We are straightforward about the fact that running payroll in-house suits plenty of businesses. If you would rather not, that is what we are here for.

                          Frequently asked questions

                          What is the best payroll software for a small business?

                          There is no single best option, because the right choice depends on your pay patterns rather than your size. Start by filtering for HMRC recognition, automatic legislative updates and full auto-enrolment handling, then check it supports the pay frequencies and payslip requirements you actually have. A package that is ideal for a salaried team of 10 can be the wrong fit for a 10-person business paying weekly with variable hours.


                           

                          Do I need payroll software if I only have one employee?

                          Yes, if you are paying anyone through PAYE, including yourself as a director. You cannot report to HMRC without software, because Real Time Information submissions have to be filed electronically. HMRC's free Basic PAYE Tools is built for businesses with fewer than 10 employees and may be enough for a single straightforward salary, though it will not cover everything, including pension contributions.


                           

                          Is there free payroll software for small businesses in the UK?

                          Yes. HMRC provides Basic PAYE Tools free for businesses with fewer than 10 employees, and several commercial providers offer free tiers for very small payrolls. The limits matter more than the price: HMRC notes that some software will not produce payslips, record or pay pension contributions, or pay people over different periods. Check those gaps against your own requirements before committing.


                           

                          How much does payroll software cost for a small business?

                          Most payroll software is priced per employee per month, often with a minimum monthly charge, and some providers use banded tiers instead. Setup, data migration, payslip portals and pension handling are sometimes charged separately, so compare the total for your headcount rather than the headline rate. Weekly payrolls generally cost more to run than monthly ones.


                           

                          Does payroll software handle pensions auto-enrolment?

                          Some does, some does not, and the difference is significant. Full handling means the software assesses every worker each pay period, produces the required letters, calculates contributions and sends the contribution file to your pension provider. Software that only calculates the deduction leaves the assessment, communications and submissions with you.


                           

                          Can my accountant access my payroll software?

                          Most cloud payroll software supports additional users with their own logins, which is usually a cleaner arrangement than emailing files. Check whether extra users cost more and what level of access they get. If your accountant currently runs payroll for you, ask whether they already use a particular package, because staying on it can make the handover considerably easier.


                           

                          Is payroll software better than using an accountant for payroll?

                          Neither is better in general. Software costs less in cash and more in your time, and the responsibility for the pay run stays with you. An accountant or payroll provider costs more in cash, takes the processing and much of the specialist knowledge off your desk, and removes the risk of payday depending on one person in your business being available. The more variable your pay, the stronger the case for handing it over.

                            Not sure payroll should stay on your desk?

                            If you have decided payroll is better off someone else's desk, we can walk you through what that would look like for a business your size, with no obligation to go further.

                              Talk to a payroll specialist