The features you cannot do without
These are the capabilities that decide whether payroll software is genuinely doing the job. Everything in the next section is optional. Nothing in this one is.
HMRC recognition and RTI
Your software must report PAYE information online, unless you are one of the few employers exempt from doing so. In practice that means using software from HMRC's list of recognised payroll software. A spreadsheet cannot file an FPS, so a spreadsheet is not an option, however small you are.
Late filing carries penalties that scale with headcount: £100 a month for 1 to 9 employees, £200 for 10 to 49, £300 for 50 to 249 and £400 for 250 or more. HMRC does not charge for your first late submission in a tax year, gives new employers 30 days from the first payment, and does not penalise an FPS that arrives within three days of payday, though filing late as a habit will attract attention.
What to ask: is the software on HMRC's recognised list, and does it submit the FPS and the EPS directly rather than asking me to key anything into HMRC's website?
Automatic updates every April
Tax bands, National Insurance thresholds, the minimum wage and statutory payment rates all change at the start of the tax year, and some change mid-year. Software that updates itself is doing real work. Software that expects you to notice a change and apply it is handing you a compliance job you did not ask for.
What to ask: are legislative updates applied automatically, included in the price, and available before 6 April rather than after it?
Auto-enrolment, properly handled
Workplace pension duties start the day your first member of staff starts working for you, not at some later threshold. You must enrol anyone aged between 22 and State Pension age who earns at least £10,000 a year and normally works in the UK, and where someone becomes eligible through a change in age or earnings you have six weeks to put them in and write to them.
This is the single biggest time saver at this size, and the feature most often missing or charged as an extra. Full handling means assessing every worker every pay period, producing the letters, calculating contributions, and sending the contribution file to your pension provider in the format it expects. Partial handling means the software does the sums and you do the rest.
What to ask: does it assess every pay period, produce the statutory communications, and send contributions to my pension provider directly?
Payslips that meet the rules
Payslips must be given to employees and workers on or before payday, and they must show pay before and after deductions, the amount of any deduction that varies, and the number of hours worked where pay varies with time worked. That last point catches out a lot of small employers with hourly staff, and it is a software capability question as much as a legal one. Printed or electronic is your choice.
What to ask: does it show variable hours on the payslip, and can staff get payslips without me emailing them individually?
Statutory pay and holiday
Statutory Sick Pay is £123.25 a week or 80% of average weekly earnings, whichever is lower, for up to 28 weeks, and it cannot be reclaimed. Family leave payments are different. You can usually reclaim 92% of statutory maternity, paternity, adoption, shared parental, parental bereavement and neonatal care pay through an EPS, and 109% if you paid £45,000 or less in Class 1 National Insurance in the last complete tax year. Your software should work the reclaim out and put it on the EPS for you.
Holiday is where entry-level software most often falls short. For leave years beginning on or after 1 April 2024, workers on irregular hours and part-year workers accrue holiday at 12.07% of the hours they actually work in each pay period, and rolled-up holiday pay is permitted for those workers. If you employ anyone on variable hours, software that tracks this is worth more to you than any dashboard.
What to ask: does it calculate holiday for irregular hours staff, and does it handle statutory payment recovery through the EPS?
Minimum wage checks and record keeping
Pay has to clear the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage for the worker's age, and deductions or salary sacrifice can quietly push an hourly rate under the floor. Software that flags this before you approve the run saves a difficult conversation later.
You must keep PAYE records for three years from the end of the tax year they relate to, and HMRC can charge up to £3,000 where records are inadequate. Minimum wage records run longer: at least six years for anything created since April 2021. Software that stores your pay records properly is doing part of this job for you, which matters if you ever face a minimum wage check.