What changes for HMRC, and what doesn't
From HMRC's point of view, changing provider is a change of software, not a change of employer. That single fact answers most of the questions people worry about.
| Item |
On a provider change |
| Your employer PAYE reference |
Stays the same |
| Your PAYE scheme |
Continues. A provider change never needs a new scheme; new schemes come from changes to the employer itself |
| Employees' employment records |
Continue unbroken. Nobody becomes a leaver or a new starter |
| P45s |
Not issued to continuing employees |
| Year-to-date figures |
Carry on cumulating from the last submission |
| Payroll IDs |
May change, and if they do, the change must be reported |
| Who sends submissions |
Your new provider's software, from the first live payroll |
| Agent access |
May need adding for the new provider and removing for the old one |
A succession is HMRC's term for a change of ownership where a different legal entity takes over the business and its pay records. That's a different situation, covered in GOV.UK's guidance on what to do if your business merges or changes ownership. More broadly, each legal entity has its own PAYE scheme, so a change of legal entity (such as incorporating, or a new owner taking over) can mean a new scheme. A change of payroll provider on its own never does. If you run several PAYE schemes, each one simply continues under its existing reference.
Why nobody gets a P45
A P45 is issued when an employee leaves your employment. GOV.UK's guidance on when an employee leaves ties it to that departure. Changing who runs your payroll doesn't end anyone's employment, so continuing employees don't get P45s, and you shouldn't report them as leavers.
Payroll IDs and the payroll ID changed indicator
This is the detail that causes most of the trouble after a switch. Each employee has a payroll ID in your submissions. Some payroll software won't let you keep the IDs your previous system used. If yours change, GOV.UK's guidance on changing payroll software says to set the "Payroll ID changed indicator" to Yes for each affected employee on your Full Payment Submission (FPS), and HMRC's guidance on what to report explains how to complete the "Old payroll ID for this employment" field alongside it. Your software may label these fields differently.
If this is missed, HMRC may treat continuing employees as new employments. GOV.UK warns that payroll records may be duplicated and your PAYE bill calculated incorrectly. The same guidance says not to include the original start date for continuing employees, and the CIPP has highlighted that sending a start date or new starter information for a continuing employee can create duplicates, leaving year-to-date figures incorrect. Duplicates are much easier to prevent than to unpick.
One exception: if you re-employ someone who left earlier in the same tax year, they get a new payroll ID and their figures restart, and the indicator is not set.
HMRC expects each FPS to carry year-to-date figures that follow on from the previous submission. In a mid-year switch, that means your new system needs every employee's year-to-date position from the old one before it sends anything.
Your Employer Payment Summary (EPS) needs checking too. Employment Allowance is claimed once per tax year, so confirm whether it has already been claimed. Also check any recovery of statutory payments, Apprenticeship Levy reporting and, for limited companies, any CIS deductions. GOV.UK's EPS guidance sets out what goes in it.
Do you need to tell HMRC?
HMRC doesn't publish a process for notifying a change of payroll provider. The change shows up in your submissions. What you do need to manage is agent access. If your new provider will deal with HMRC on your behalf, it needs authorising as your agent, through Online Agent Authorisation, your business tax account or form 64-8, as set out in GOV.UK's guidance on agent authorisation.
Whoever runs your payroll, you remain legally responsible for your PAYE obligations. GOV.UK's guidance on choosing how to run payroll is clear on that.